pointer problems

In chapter four, Hyde introduces a variety of data types and declarations,
including how to declare and use constants, scalar variables, integers, reals,
“data types”, pointers, arrays, records/structures, unions and namespaces.

Hyde’s HLA includes the concept of constants, as I understand them – a named
element assigned some value that cannot change during compilation or execution.
But oddly, HLA includes VALs as well. These are “constants” that can change
value during compilation and execution. What distinguishes them from normal
variables, isn’t clear to me yet.

This chapter also includes coverage of pointers and common issues with their usage including:

  • Using an uninitialized pointer
  • Using a pointer that contains an illegal value (e.g. NULL)
  • Continuing to use malloc’d storage after that storage has been freed
  • Faling to free storage once the program is done using it
  • Accessing indirect data using the wrong data type

The first issue is easily understood. When a pointer is declared, storage is allocated for the pointer itself, but the pointer references address zero, rather than a memory address of the developer’s choosing. If the developer does not assign the pointer to a memory address to which they have access, the results can be unpredictable. In my testing, a memory access violation was consistently thrown.

The second issue can arise when the developer miscalculates the address that they want to assign to a pointer and rather than pointing where it should, it points somewhere it should not, not zero as in the previous example. In this case, it may point to a location in memory that the program can access, but the data there may not be correct for the application and this can result in errors that are difficult to debug.

The third issue doesn’t seem like a pointer issue as much as it is a memory management problem. Attempting to access a pointer that references a freed memory segment is a use after free issue and depending on the specifics, the application could work just fine, could fail unpredictably and again may be difficult to troubleshoot.

Failure to free storage after use is again more of a memory management issue than a pointer issue, in my mind, but could result in classic memory leaks.

The last issue arises because HLA and probably other languages that use pointers don’t enforce pointer-type-safety, meaning the compiler doesn’t check that the pointer being referenced is used in a type-safe manner. You may be treating the data at a given address as a character, when it should be treated as double word hexadecimal – the text has some example programs that cover some of these issues.

Written on January 25, 2020